With all due respect, the analysis that this “proves” all of these things is quite a strong claim.
It is, at least, equally as possible that BIP-110 was simply not a good enough of an idea for most of the network to want to adopt it.
Just because BIP-110 didn’t pass, doesn’t mean that somehow that Bitcoin is too centralized. It could also just be a humility test that a better idea is needed.
There are so many better ideas to solve these issues than BIP-110. Such as removing the witness discount.
brightmindsco / Sydney Bright
npub124…6ys0r
2026-08-18 13:56:42 UTC
in reply to nevent1q…wlpg
Author Public Key
npub1249tdlkkwkv966uek7dd0duyl7x2ffdsyaugztsedrhwp3ktcflq66ys0rPublished at
2026-08-18 13:56:42 UTCEvent JSON
{
"id": "439937a33911c46b44735db7c9001febe51cbb60395639a98aaab9f9e74f45bc",
"pubkey": "554ab6fed675985d6b99b79ad7b784ff8ca4a5b02778812e1968eee0c6cbc27e",
"created_at": 1787061402,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"7f0fd320f990e2ae3f3eb2dd9fcfb0cc56c4e77f277cca40af2f71cf4fa18f51",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"154d277345c96359aa8aec02be998cb622052c550ab9cfc3e63aa9784ca3922d",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"97cb5377fb6c4a5143eadbdba4b292f3b6df2f14b4256bbaa0c1e163900d6737",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"client",
"Primal iOS"
]
],
"content": "With all due respect, the analysis that this “proves” all of these things is quite a strong claim. \n\nIt is, at least, equally as possible that BIP-110 was simply not a good enough of an idea for most of the network to want to adopt it. \n\nJust because BIP-110 didn’t pass, doesn’t mean that somehow that Bitcoin is too centralized. It could also just be a humility test that a better idea is needed. \n\nThere are so many better ideas to solve these issues than BIP-110. Such as removing the witness discount. ",
"sig": "9ff8766cd991b77fc3023d519bbd1c6fedcfc8737d42d343be9b745835bf61be43ecd9031b7916fa8044dbda568be658a329d65aa7f01fdd2ce8ac27a057ff3e"
}