Join Nostr
2026-10-23 14:01:43 UTC
in reply to

Michael K Johnson on Nostr: Linear encoders in a heated chamber would need precise temperature measurement and ...

Linear encoders in a heated chamber would need precise temperature measurement and compensation; an unnecessary complication.

Rotary encoders on the motors are cheaper, don't suffer from the expansion problem (radial position isn't affected by thermal expansion), and are well understood. It's possible to substitute closed-loop steppers that integrate the rotary encoders with feedback control. If you skip a tooth on the belt you have a much larger problem.

You can go faster with (more expensive) servos with rotary encoders, but so far consumer 3d printing hasn't generally needed speed/torque combinations that are hard to achieve with steppers.