Join Nostr
2026-11-15 11:51:29 UTC

nostrvault on Nostr: We took the houses part literally. When we started Nostr Vault, we were sleeping on ...

We took the houses part literally.

When we started Nostr Vault, we were sleeping on the streets like everyone else. Our notes lived on other people's relays, our photos on other people's servers, and every app we opened walked us straight back into the square.

So we started building a house.

The first room was a vault: a relay of your own that lives on your phone, keeps every note you write and every photo you post, and answers to you. Then we added more rooms. Your Mac became a vault. Your Android became a vault. Soon a little Linux box in the closet can be one, running all day.

Then we needed hallways. A house is not a house if you have to step outside to get from the kitchen to the bedroom. So the vaults talk to each other over a private mesh, device to device, without asking a public relay for permission and without telling the street where you live.

Then a front door with a mail slot. Your web of trust decides who can leave notes for you: people you follow, and the people they follow. Anyone can read what you post on the street, but only your people can leave a note at your door.

The square is still there. You can walk out any time, post, read, argue. But you come home at night, and everything you made is still in your house, in your hands.

I think is right: the square only fills up once there is a town around it. We are trying to build one house at a time, and to make it easy enough that anyone can own one.

#grownostr #nostrvault #NV
Nostr was proposed as a way to create a global public square, but after way too many years I realized this can't be its initial driving force, only the final outcome of multiple different driving forces.

An analogy that came to my mind is that in order to have a true public square we have to have all the houses and buildings around it. What we have on Nostr now is like a bunch of people sleeping on the streets, in a town with no houses.

So if we want Nostr to not just linger and die we have to start building the houses.

First, take all these people who are currently on the streets and put them into a big house with glass walls called wss://relay.primal.net + wss://nos.lol. Then create new buildings, by which of course I mean other relays with different rules and made for different people.

It will probably not work to just launch new relays and hope people will come using the same Nostr apps we currently use. It also doesn't make any sense to do what I and almost everybody else have done in the past 4 years and try to market this only to the people inside Nostr.

I think the idea is to just market your new vibecoded app as a gateway to one specific relay-based niche platform, or as a way to create your own relay-based community. This stuff has to be initially separate from "the current Nostr" community -- i.e. no "fallback relays", no "trending", no "global search", but if your new vibecoded app allows browsing different houses you can just frame "the current Nostr" as one of these.

The current apps we have are very amazing, with all their outboxes and threaded feeds and multi-kind support, and it is sad that only a small part of the world can experiment with them for now. But because they are optimized for the public square they should probably be paused and deemphasized for a while we don't have at least 3 other solid buildings in the Nostr town.

I don't know what I'm saying anymore, just wanted to leave this here.