Join Nostr
2026-11-15 17:14:14 UTC

Chris Trottier on Nostr: So I've been wondering: what's the difference between this literal can of shit and ...

So I've been wondering: what's the difference between this literal can of shit and AI-generated art?

One of them is critically acclaimed and the other is not.

And it's not the AI-generated artwork that critics love. It's the can of shit—also known as Artist's Shit by Piero Manzoni.

But why is that?

After all, they take about the same effort to produce. With the AI-generated artwork, you need *some* creativity in the sense that you have to write a prompt. Artist's Shit merely requires defecating—which we all must do—and then canning it.

The difference is in the meta-narrative.

Or a better analogy is to look at the world of pro wrestling.

We all know that pro wrestling is scripted and fake. It's not a competition. No one wins the championship belt because they were the superior athlete.

But on January 4, 1999, a scandal erupted in the world of pro-wrestling and lead directly to the collapse of WCW.

This became known as the Fingerpoke of Doom.

Wikipedia describes what happened thus:

> The match opened with Nash and Hogan slowly circling each other. After a few moments, Nash shoved Hogan into the corner of the ring and further taunted him. In response, Hogan prepared to throw a punch at Nash, only to stop and casually poke Nash in the chest instead. Nash fell on his back in a theatrical manner, which has been compared to "getting hit in the chest with a cannonball". Hogan then covered him to get the pinfall and was declared the new WCW World Heavyweight Champion.

Now why did this anger fans when they already know wrestling is fake?

Because it's not about the effort, but the illusion of effort.

Once audiences recognise that prestige can be conferred without the achievement supposedly required to earn it, institutional authority becomes questionable.

And this applies to fine art as well.

When we look at Artist's Shit, it's not about the effort, but the illusion of effort. Sure, anyone can shit. But can they shit while delivering it with such artifice as a can, a label, and a signature—carefully numbered so you know it's 1 can in a set of 100?

On the other hand, AI-generated art is the Fingerpoke of Doom equivalent to art.

Sure, it might look objectively "good". Better than Artist's Shit too. But once you puncture the meta-narrative about the *illusory effort* of art, then its value becomes questionable.

And this is why people *actually* hate AI-generated art.